Sunday, 13 March 2016

Finding radiance



Seeing Foyer as an approach, rather than bricks and mortar, has been a consistent message from Foyer Federation over the years.  It is a focus that helps unpick the stereotype of ‘youth homelessness’ to reveal the more complex mix of social and personal challenges that require better offers than just a bed for the night.  More than a place to stay, Foyers were always about communities of learning to connect and find one’s place in the world. 

In my time at Foyer Federation, when I worked on the Foyer Accreditation framework, it was the staff and young people in projects I remembered more than the buildings they worked and lived in.  Yet, the buildings left their mark.  Thankfully, few were places that were unfit for young people. Most gave glimpses of design innovations to accommodate the Foyer ethos as a living community – creating a sense of space, energy, interaction and progression. A running joke over the years was to have the architects over for the night, so they could live with the good and bad they left behind. New Foyers did not always learn from the past – and while great ideas got handed down through the Accreditation framework, design errors were sometimes replicated by those who didn't listen to learn. 

The origins of Foyer as a concept comes from France.  Over the years the Federation always kept cordial relations with Paris, with a few shared visits.  Ironically, though, it was travel to USA which brought back more ideas in my work as Director of Innovation. Visits to New York and Philadelphia led to a focus on assets that drove the early development of Open Talent and Advantaged Thinking.  In those philosophies, the idea of ‘place’ came to the foreground as a form of inquiry into the type of environment where young people could best develop and harness their talents in life. It is a powerful question which is always best left open, as every age must shape its own answers.  Perhaps it is the job of Foyers to sustain this conversation at the community level, re-applying the Foyer ethos and approach over time.  Indeed, the best projects I visited were those flexible and forward thinking enough to keep redeveloping themselves in the moment. 

I was fortunate to begin my 2016 in Marseille, with a final slot on my itinerary to check out Le Corbusier’s Cité radieuse (Radiant City), the modernist flagship for his vision of Unité d'habitation.  I left regretting I had not visited before. For here was a project of bricks and mortar, in which a vision of life had been cemented into the design.  The stunning sense of space and light, shops, businesses, educational facilities, and breath taking rooftop views, enshrined an approach to community living that still inspires people to live there today.  While not a Foyer for young people, anyone who knows a Foyer would have instantly recognised its principles.  Of course, history will point to how Corbusier’s vision came unstuck in some of the less well conceived housing estates designed by others in Great Britain.  But there are important things to learn when one sees, in the original building, the essential features and intent that were foolishly disregarded in the flawed projects that followed.  It is a lesson in what happens when a founding vision is lost from the bricks and mortar. Le Corbusier’s Cité radieuse was a work of art.  Where is its equivalent as an offer for young people today?  What might be a future way of living that offers a solution to the shifting sands of youth housing and employment? 

Watching the sun sink into the rooftops, I felt three messages from Corbusier grip my mind: 

  1. That there must be a strong guiding vision and philosophy for what we wish to create, ambitious and radical enough to shape a positive vision for future living; 
  1. That the vision and philosophy of the ethos must not be compromised in its inception, or, most particularly, its replication – for once the approach enshrined into the design of bricks and mortar is taken apart and diluted, the promise of radiance disappears; 
  1. That, to ensure the above, we need a collaborative development framework for our new vision and philosophy to guide how and what we do so we maximise its potential over time. 

Those messages are even more important following David Cameron’s recent promise (or not) to ‘regenerate’ UK housing estates.  The message to ‘rebuild houses that people feel they can have a real future in’ is one that Corbusier would surely recognise; though I expect he would also ask, what the vision and philosophy behind the message is.   

Whether demolishing and rebuilding estates, or seeking to sustain or redevelop Foyers, it is the bricks and mortar of inspirational thinking that is most precious. 

At InspireChilli, we take inspiration seriously.  So did Corbusier. Shouldn’t you?

Check out the new InspireChill offer 

Monday, 23 November 2015

Anger is an energy



Cathy Come Home was a BBC television play from 1966 about the lives of people experiencing homelessness.  Back then, our popular vision of 21st century living was unlikely to include a society where people struggling to find work are handed sanctions instead of support and depend on food handouts to survive.  But that is where we have got to in the current script for Aspirational Britain. Ken Loach, Director of Cathy Come Home, has called for ‘public rage’ on the issue. 

In 1966, Loach recalls, people who learned a trade could get a job for life.  Now there seem fewer guarantees for working people to be in control of their destiny.  Loach sees it as part of a system of ‘conscious cruelty’.   In a nutshell, the popular image of ‘skivers and striders’ has manipulated the narrative of the ‘deserving of the underserving poor’ to cover up the failures to manage a changing economic system as capitalism enters a new phase of development.  Indeed the ‘politics of cruelty’ feels an apt phrase for a period of modern government presiding over growing levels of division in wealth and assets.  It was symbolic that Loach’s comments quoted in The Guardian were reported on the same day that Joseph Rowntree’s report on Monitoring Poverty and Social Exclusion    painted a dismal view of a society where significant numbers of young people are being hung out to dry (Four times more likely to be unemployed, 5 times more likely to be on zero hours contract, with the numbers of kids in poverty in private rented housing doubled over ten years). These days, young Cathy’s are being told to F-off as the welfare state is shrink-wrapped before our eyes.

Cathy Come Home’s portrayal of homelessness and poverty on TV in 1966 was quickly followed with the establishment of charities Crisis and Shelter. While public interest never followed through into systemic reform of the causes of homelessness, it set the ball rolling for a wave of innovations, including the introduction of the Foyer Movement to address youth disadvantage, and the Places for Change programme to transform services for people experiencing rough sleeping.  Fast forward from 1966 to 2015, and where is the rage that Loach calls for?  What has really changed in how we ‘deal’ with disadvantage in modern Britain? What would housing campaigner Shelia Mckechnie say, who served as a Director at Shelter in 1985 where she helped to set up the Foyer Foundation in the 1990s? I expect she would have written a far better blog than I can.  She would have certainly written something in the void.

Over the last few years, I’ve met countless people defending the use of negative charity advertising against my critique that it does nothing to engage public consciousness in changing the narrative of disadvantage.  The consequent dangers become very evident in the ‘conscious cruelty’ played out in the reform of welfare and tagging of so-called ‘skivers’. After all, nobody does the narrative of disadvantage better than a Government seeking to deploy austerity to reduce the size of the state and trickle down its debt.  Every exploitative fundraising poster and self-serving campaign only fuels a social consciousness that is unable to see beyond the stereotypes and is increasingly mistrusting of the message.  It is when we are challenged to see other people as we do our own children or our self, that we realise the people we dehumanise as ‘homeless’ are worth investing in with a ‘hand up rather than hand out’.  This is the whole point and purpose of what I called Advantaged Thinking at the Foyer Federation: to understand people as people and thus find the best ways to develop their abilities, skills, resources and connections so they stand a chance of thriving in the future. The real issue is why we can't  create advantage in everyone instead of our obsession with disadvantage.


So where is the ‘rage’ tonight, this week, this month, this year, about what is happening to young people - and what we can do to make a difference to harness the abilities of those in danger of being 'youth labour's lost' (Demos, 2011)?  For Cathy to come anywhere near home now, charity needs to find its capacity and locus of control to inspire meaningful social change.  And by inspiration, I mean the 1% genius type of solutions, not the 99% of fundraising perspiration it has got mistaken for - understandably though, in part, through the current squeeze on resource.  It’s not Cathy who needs a sanction; it’s the ‘conscious cruelty’ that defines what we cruelly mistake for leadership in the politics of our times. 

 John Lydon once sang that ‘anger is an energy’.  Some anger about the lack of an alternative offer might be a good thing.  But the rage Loach is calling for is best defined as the articulate voice of people who give a shit, have an idea, and can focus on the mission to deploy the resource required to actually get it done. 

www.inspirechilli.com -

Monday, 16 November 2015

The Armour of Amour




As the sound of gunfire hit Paris, I received an email with the subject heading ‘love’.  Inside, the words breathed its opposite: someone who decided that my writing about love was a sign of evil.  I had been ‘noted’ it accused – unlike the writer, instantly dismissible among the horrors of the night.
Like all coincidences, receiving an unloving email at a moment of such tragic significance must have a meaning.   Somewhere between young men firing machine guns at a culture they rejected with such profound hate, and our growing mistrust of what is and is not good around us, there will be a connection we need to make about trust, belonging, and love or 'amour' as they say in France.

There is lots to feel proud about in our collective response to Paris. But it can’t remove our focus from an age where the connections between people, our sense of social inclusion, grows increasingly fractured through the economic and social challenges that face us.  The roots and foundations of our social values are shaken on a daily basis in tiny ways that the horror of Friday explodes into consciousness from a different but linked perspective.  While we defend ourselves with the notion that these people we call terrorists were not human, we fool ourselves from the truth that the atrocity committed perpetuates throughout history our dangerous capacity for exclusive extremes.  The question is, how can humans be driven to commit actions of such inhumanity?  The ability to love and hate at the same time, to do and be in entirely different ways, is the darkness within which everything inauthentic, manipulative and deceitful lives in our history.  Exploitative fundraising practices and the policies of austerity might feel a very long distance from suicide bombers on the streets, but they are all on the same tarnished road to an extreme place where our humanity for each other slowly dies.

It would be easy to think that charity has no purpose to offer at a time when missile strikes and security become the order of the day.  But I can think of no other moment when there is such a desperate need for charity to shine out the leadership our age calls for.  The real war is far bigger than a country or cause. The war for our future is as much with ourselves, our concept of what it is to be human, and our capacity to create the conditions to maximise love, trust and belonging in our society and world.  It is not just additional armed guards that will protect us now; it’s also the arming of values and purpose for a better world. The armour of 'amour'.

I feel no shame to believe in a sector that should nurture communities of love within itself and those it cares for.  I feel nothing to hide about demanding that youth charity should be shaping communities of greater belonging and authenticity, for which its ability to collaborate, create meaning, harness diminishing resource, and believe in what young people can do, all need to be upped in urgency. 


At the time of the London riots in 2011, the Foyer Federation wrote a powerful analysis about the importance of giving young people a stake-in-society, and the positive effects for us all when young people have something of value they do not wish to lose.  It’s a vision worth holding onto over the winter ahead of us.  While we react to the threat of terror around us, we must also pro-act to create its opposite through an equal intent for good.  How we choose to love and invest in our young people now might never have been so important.

www.inspirechilli.com

Thursday, 12 November 2015

Why we are missing one percent



Say ‘one percent’ to someone from a housing association, and the face that will greet you is unlikely to be smiling with energy.  One percent has become the vexed question of how associations can find unplanned savings to fill the sudden hole in the fuselage exposed by the Government’s demand for 1% reduction in social housing rents to restrict the spiraling costs of welfare.  A redistribution in cuts, as one put it to me.  Perhaps the choice of one percent is purely mathematical, but it’s a phrase of symbolic depth that can offer insights into the current drama preoccupying minds and budgets.

2006 saw the heir to the Johnson and Johnson fortune release a film called One Percent.  It was a documentary alerting us to the dangers of a world in which a small group of super rich owned nearly half of the wealth in America.  The phrase stuck, and by 2015 Sam Wilkin was sharing the low down of how we too could join the world’s new elite through ‘Wealth Secrets of the One Percent’. The commodification of the aspiration to ‘make it’ as a member of capitalism’s VIP class had a catchy name in the new evolution of one percent societies.  It’s a trend with many dangers, as outlined in the stats from the Amex-Harrison ‘Survey of Affluence and Wealth in America’ (2012).   The behaviour patterns of the one percent in the survey suggested a sense of increasing disengagement in risk taking activity to benefit others, played out against a society in which the one percent were increasingly vilified by those not in the club (Amex-Harrison, 2012).   Part of the Government’s justification for its ‘one percent’ is that housing associations, with large surpluses, have become part of their own one-percent style club in the ecosystem of social profits.  Only that view is to grossly simplify a more complex picture.  A one percent cut for a housing association in the top deck might in the end be affordable, by reducing services and switching priorities; but for smaller organisations, without the luxury of choice, one percent can mean the difference between running a service and merely keeping it going.  As ever, our approach to distributing assets and deficits across society ends up deepening existing economic divisions.

When the cuts are played out, what becomes evident is that they are the lazy policy tool of a system that has lost an important one percent in its thinking mind.  I refer here to the 1% genius in Thomas Edison’s famous equation of what should drive our 99% perspiration of doing.  A one percent cut is now defining business decisions in a way that lacks good business sense.  We have all the perspiration at the moment with none of the genius.  Sure, savings to the public purse might be made from reduced welfare costs for social rents, but the quality of support available to people in welfare will in some cases be reduced as organisations without capacity cut off limbs to keep crawling.  In the long term, that means social savings today will be stolen back at twice the cost in whatever system we have left to pay for the carnage of future care for those affected.  Why? Because a one percent cut is not a solution to the question of how best to support people through welfare and what happens to them; it’s merely a reaction to the aspiration that we should spend less on doing it. 

The important thing is here is the question of technology.  The one percent cut is a form of economic technology that looks like a hybrid between the Trotter van from 'Only Fools and Horses' and a surgeon trying to delicately reshape the human brain with a jackhammer. It’s as lacking in sophistication as it is in ability to achieve a positive outcome.  I use the term technology here for a reason.  The one percent in Edison’s phrase is very much a different type of technology – the genius to find the source of thinking and action that can transform what we do; or what entrepreneur Peter Thiel calls the jump from ‘zero to one’. Applied in our social context, it should be the one percent that focuses us on the deeper questions of how we do welfare and how we provide people with access to homes.

I don’t think our welfare system requires either a one percent cut or a one percent increase; nor do the housing association social rents linked to them.  What is needed is a different approach to what welfare is meant to be and do; what its outcomes are meant to achieve; what type of society we are trying to create together; and how we can make the smartest investment decisions to maximise our potential.   For that to happen, services need ‘freedom with expectation’ to create the small steps out of our current game of coping with disadvantages and cuts – the type of ‘one percenter’ sprints, kicks and tackles which, in Australian rules football, are known to win games.  Welfare is fast becoming a losing game that needs to be revitalised and strengthened with a different carrot and stick.

Should the Government and social good sector wish to trade in the Trotter van and jackhammer, what and where is the technology to replace it? The technology of one percent inspiration is not easy to source, partly because our understanding of inspiration is wholly inadequate to the task.  Countless programmes, initiatives and organisations use the inspiration label, but few have ever properly researched into the DNA of what inspiration is, how it can be harnessed, and its huge potential to transform current work.  While vast amounts are now written about theory of change logic models, there is little attention to the science and art of inspiration.  Now is not the time to buffer up the Trotter Van for one more drive round the policy block, one more spin in charity’s Nurburgring of funding crashes.  We must  look into and beyond ourselves for how we can find a different technology to reimagine our futures.  I call that the technology of Social Inspiration.  I can’t guarantee it will get you a life of wealth, but I’m 99% sure it will find the one percent we are missing.


The Social Inspirator’s curriculum is due for release in the early New Year at www.inspirechilli.com

Saturday, 24 October 2015

Safe to take risks


Some thoughts on risk, energy and inspiration from the UK MassChallenge Awards and Fundraising event


The UK MassChallenge Awards ceremony had the (relatively) easy task last Thursday of handing out 500k to inspiring start up enterprises. The bigger challenge was ensuring its speakers could be heard above the excited hubbub at the cavernous Truman’s Brewery in Brick Lane.

Azmat Yusuf, Founder and CEO of Citymapper, was one of the keynotes whose words might easily have been overshadowed by the drinks and dinner, were it not that his series of throwaway personal reflections had far more gems than bread crusts.  Shining among them was the suggestion that, in the current world of changes and disruptions to our social and economic narrative, it was actually ‘safer to take risks than not to do so at all’.  While this could have been just another Pinkie and the Brain style story of start-ups trying to take over the world, it seemed to touch on something important about what the start-up culture represents.

Speak to most of the audience at an event like MassChallenge, and among the entrepreneurs and investors is an oft repeated focus on the idea of disruptive technology.  Coding and enterprise has seemingly created its own brand of Punk, replacing CBGBs with the city co-working space.  But the fascination with the disruptive  often negates a simpler  truth: that we are by default living in a wider historical narrative that is already in a state of disruption to many of its existing norms – whether it’s pensions, housing, migration, employment, ageing, etc. Most things in fact, except of course the unequal distribution of wealth and our inability to seek a meaningful solution to social disadvantage.  Being disruptive is becoming a state of survival.  It’s not something to be cocky about.  Rather, it’s something to be deeply concerned that the discipline of disruption is not better integrated into the mainstream of the charity and beyond profit sector where social good most needs to flourish.

If our world is truly one where risk and disruption to our social fabric is here to stay, then surely the only safe option is to take the risks that might enable us to gain back control of where our personal narratives might be heading.  In my own humble story, I’ve taken a risk by leaving a brilliant job at a good, respectable charity I care about, in order to set up my own business with a very limited pipeline of work.  My position might be precarious, but on the flipside, it’s meant I have started developing the technology of Social Inspiration that is light years ahead of my previous innovations.  Intellectually and ethically, it’s a risk whose value is greater than the danger of staying in an environment where radical ideas are harder to develop and control. 

Let’s apply the same concept to young people making the transition into adulthood.  The idea of that journey being a transition feels like it has reached its ‘think-by-date’ in modern society.  Transition is a nostalgia for a world where there might have once been fixed positions to move from and to.  The reality is better marked through the shift from being a character in a story to gradually taking on more of its authorship, seeking greater control over the positive risks required to achieve a lived life.  That is not so much a transition in states; it’s more a rites-of-passage rupture from a narrative of greater dependency into the rights and responsibilities that a lived life brings.  Only it is getting harder for the rite to be all embracing as the controls over what Thomas Paine called ‘the rights of man’ are increasingly complicated.  How many of us have control over somewhere to live, or the fruits of our labour? If it’s a shift in risks, it’s spiky and subtle. And it is grotesquely unequal in terms of the greater risks that some people are expected to carry while being pelted as scroungers without grit.  The determining factor better lies in the self-knowledge and capacity to be able to ‘disrupt’ from one identity to another, from this narrative to the next.  We can be heroes, as Bowie sang.  At least, if we can find a way to access the knowledge and capacity.

There are two ideas that might help us shape a different view of the risk and transitions agenda for young people.

The first is the sustainable livelihood’s approach I introduced into the Foyer Federation network, with its distinctions between coping with limited short term risk but greater longer term risks; adapting or building towards longer term stability with higher short term risk; and a thriving state where risks are more positive than negative.  The innovation in the charity sector should be in the middle process of adaption, though far greater resource is spent on the short term-ism of the coping stereotype of charity – the ‘bed for the night’ campaign; or at a management level 'funding for the gap'.  The real crisis is that the crisis management approach to budget control, and crisis-led interventions to young people’s risks, ultimately remove any possibility that charity can solve the issues it seeks to address.    

The second idea is the concept of ‘breakthrough’ led by the work of those such as Youth at Risk, a charity whose purpose is lived in its name.  The young people they are interested might well be ‘youth at risk’ in terms of their position in society and our traditional understanding of personal narratives of disadvantage; but the charity's intent, using the power of transformational coaching, is to put those people into positive experiences of risk where they can breakout of set positions and narratives to make the disruptive leap into a different possibility of being.  It’s an approach I wish could be applied to the charity sector as a whole.  The danger, as we are beginning to see in current closures and mergers, is that charity often can’t afford to be risky enough to create a better world. 

At the end of MassChallenge, I was struck by the power of the boldly branded MC logo and its subliminal reference to Einstein’s theory of relativity.  Is the real challenge the missing part of Einstein’s equation: the concept of energy needed to bring the challenge of positive risks into the mass of the charity mainstream?  To develop that energy requires a significant freeing of the leadership and resource that constrains individuals working within the youth charity sector.  How it might be achieved is exactly the type of mass challenge I am exploring at InspireChilli.  We call it the 1% solution.  99% of people's time is spent on the perspiration required to move between surviving and coping; so what is the 1% inspiration that will drive us to breakthrough the risks into thriving solutions?  Inspiration is not a minor thing to be subjugated to efficient management processes and procedures. It’s the pure, visionary, disruptive, passionate ‘chilli’ energy that can enable us to live the challenge life poses each day - to be its potential.

Charity cannot afford to ignore that we are in a world where it is safer and necessary to take risks. We need to bottle the inspiration to embrace those risks positively, so, as a sector and society, we don’t keep ‘bottling it’ when it comes to young people.

With thanks to the MassChallenge team and community for a great night.

www.inspirechilli.com -
making social inspiration work for good

Wednesday, 7 October 2015

Building ideas to build housing


My interest in charity as a form of art – see last blog - led me last week to MoMA, the Museum of Modern Art in New York.  Let’s just say I needed a holiday and got lucky.  New York might have a reputation for the merging of various boundaries, but what caught my eye was the potential in an exhibition title of: 
‘Endless House: Intersections of Art and Architecture’.  


Modern art has constantly pushed our understanding of its identity and purpose, for which an embrace of architecture seems a natural progression from rooms full of Picasso and Warhol.   Our social dialogue on designing a better sense of place has obvious merit as an inquiry to explore visions of future humanity. What we can do, who we can be and how?  At least, it is when you have the right minds in the room like at MoMA.

I was gripped by the breadth of ideas and imagination on display.  From concepts for mobile home ‘escape vehicles’ to ‘shelter for people living in precarious conditions’, the art and architecture explored deep issues of human psychology and social need.  The creators clearly inhabited a world in which people were still trying to build a positive future of wonder; a world prepared to think in a different language of possibility and challenge. It’s a dying art.

The MoMA's exhibition centred on the fascinating works of Austrian American artist Frederick Kiesler.  In the 1920’s, Keisler began to map out a form of ‘endless architecture’ that merged art and architecture into living forms of infinite creation. Keisler’s explorations led to the Endless House – an organic model for a new type of single-family accommodation that was as much interested in people’s spiritual and physical needs for a form of residence as it was in the concept of a dwelling being a more fluid process of arranging different textures, light and space. Keisler concluded, ‘the house must be a cosmos in itself, a transformer of life-forces’. 

What is in our cosmos? David Cameron’s vow to scrap the requirement to build affordable homes for rent is more likely to find future favour in a shop of horrors than an art gallery.   Yet, it was the announcement today that brought to my mind Keisler and the MoMA. The power of thinking in new directions is a real lack in so much current policy and programmes associated with housing. Are we really asking the deep questions to be able to imagine the right answers?  If we wish to embrace the housing pressures from young people and older people in their different life transitions, then we need to build a different way of thinking about housing, people and communities.  It’s no surprise ‘Endless House’ offers more provocations as to what that might look like than any soundbites from this season’s party conferences.

The Museum of Modern Art promotes itself as ‘a place that fuels creativity, ignites minds, and provides inspiration’.  But you don’t have to go all the way to New York to find it.  At InspireChilli, we believe the source for creativity exists inside organisations and people who learn how to fuel the ‘art of social inspiration’.  It’s the intersection between charity and art where future bold designs for housing will flourish.  Just ask for a hot ticket to make it happen.